Reviews (14)
Write a review
Best colby cheese I have ever had the pleasure of eating.
Mild but full of flavor. Great texture, creaminess and consistency.
Posted by Patrick Curry on May 29th 2026
I Love ❤️ this Colby cheese!! I Eat some Daily! I used to be able to get it at my local Hy-Vee, but they seem to have since discontinued this Colby! ?. Found the Makers Website and Ordered a few blocks of my Beloved Colby Cheese! Packaged Super Well and was Shipped to my house Within 3 or 4 days!! Glad I found the Actual Go-To Source!!
Posted by Cortney on Mar 28th 2026
Our very favorite colby cheese!
Posted by Cindy on Jan 18th 2025
Fast, accurate delivery of great tasting cheese. My new favorite cheese is Colby, which has excellent flavor. Local, NATURAL cheese which should be supported by WI residents.
Posted by Platz on Apr 11th 2024
I am so thrilled with their service and the quality of their cheeses. We tell everyone we know about them! Especially those who are posted with us overseas.
Posted by Jennifer Smith on Jan 6th 2024
Creamy with excellent flavor! One of my all time favorites!
Posted by Bob on Dec 31st 2023
A Christmas gift for family in Tennessee and loved!
Posted by Judie Nelson on Dec 28th 2023
Great for snacking with Sausage or Crackers.
Try some you will see for yourself.
Posted by Neil on Dec 25th 2022
I have been looking for a delicious Colby cheese that is similar to the wonderful colby my mother used to get. This is the closest I've found. Delicious, mild and sweet. Thank you.
Posted by Judy Bianco on Oct 21st 2022
Best Colby around hands down.
Posted by Sara on Jun 17th 2022
Not only was the Colby cheese delicious, but the delivery was amazing! Thank you for the wonderful service:)
Susan
Posted by Susan on Jan 18th 2022
All of you products that I have ordered have been great.
Posted by Scott Hanlon on Dec 30th 2021
This is the best Colby cheese I have ever tasted hands down!
Posted by RandyGrurmmer on Jan 14th 2021
One of the best cheeses I have ever had.
Posted by Kelly on Apr 26th 2020